Indoor air is not Coronavirus ready!
Oliver Zimmermann, CEO of Condair Group, comments on the lack of humidity control regulations for public places and the subsequent impact on possible coronavirus transmission and the nation’s health.
Public building occupants are being exposed to increased risk from viruses, such as the coronavirus, because the regulations on indoor air quality (IAQ) are falling short of current scientific knowledge. Maintaining IAQ at above 40%RH has been scientifically shown to reduce viral cross infection, including coronavirus and influenza. Yet out-of-date regulations on the topic result in buildings such as hospitals, offices and schools experiencing dangerously low humidity levels every winter.
Studies, such as Casanova et al 20101, have specifically examined humidity’s role in coronavirus transmission. This study showed that coronavirus was deactivated fastest when exposed to a mid-range humidity (50%RH), rather than dry (20%RH) or damp (80%RH) air. There are many other studies, dating back from the 40s to now, that all indicate that an indoor humidity of 40-60%RH has a positive impact on cross infection and people’s susceptibility to viruses. Alongside Casanova et al 2010, summaries of 25 other such studies are listed on our website, condair.com.
The building services sector accepts this indoor humidity level as being best practise, with many professional organisations endorsing a mid-range humidity for health in their recommendations. However, there are no official regulations that set an acceptable range of indoor humidity for public places. Therefore, building designers, who are driven to reduce energy consumption and costs, do not commonly include humidity control in their plans.
The seasonality of viruses, such as coronaviruses and influenza, are further evidence of humidity’s role in their transmission. Indoor air is much drier in the winter and this corresponds to the rise of infections. Strategies to contain the spread of the virus frequently cite the assumption that infections will probably drop as warmer weather returns, and indoor humidity levels naturally return to a midrange 40-60%RH. It doesn’t need to be this way! A healthy indoor humidity can be maintained during winter if buildings incorporated humidification as part of the ventilation system. This would significantly reduce seasonal ‘flu transmission and save thousands of lives globally every year.
Advice on mitigating the risk from coronavirus largely focuses on hand hygiene and avoiding unwell people. However, viral cross infection occurs via the air as well as from physical contact. As the general public are largely helpless to manage this important aspect of infection control, government advice ignores this topic.
The responsibility to manage IAQ ultimately falls on building owners and operators to safeguard occupant health. This is particularly true with regards healthcare facilities, where people are most vulnerable and at risk to airborne infections, such as coronavirus and influenza. The general public are being failed in this respect with no health authority in the world specifying a minimum humidity level in waiting rooms or wards.
Given the overwhelming scientific evidence for indoor humidity of 40-60%RH being an effective infection control mechanism, and the pending viral pandemic on our doorstep, regulatory bodies must listen to the science and set acceptable indoor humidity levels for health.
Prof. Dr. med. Adriano Aguzzi
University of Zurich. Professor of neuropathology and director of the Institute of Neuropathology. Won a NOMIS Distinguished Scientist Award for his research into neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s.
Prof. Dr. Akiko Iwasaki
Research scientist at Yale University. Led a recently published study on humidity’s impact on influenza infection.
Stephanie Taylor, MD.
Infection Control Consultant at Harvard Medical School and Distinguished ASHRAE Lecturer. Expert on the built environment and indoor air quality.
Dr. med. Walter Hugentobler.
Lecturer Institute for Primary Care University and University Hospital Zurich. Medical and academic consultant with 30 years’ experience on the topic of humidity’s impact on health.
CEO at Condair Group. The Condair Group is the world’s leading specialist in humidification and commercial humidity control. High resolution image available here.
1 - Effects of Air Temperature and Relative Humidity on Coronavirus Survival on Surfaces. Lisa M. Casanova, Soyoung Jeon, William A. Rutala, David J. Weber, Mark D. Sobsey. Applied and Environmental Microbiology Apr 2010, 76 (9) 2712-2717; DOI: 10.1128/AEM.02291-09
Oliver Zimmermann, CEO at Condair Group.
Maintaining IAQ at above 40%RH has been scientifically shown to reduce viral cross infection...